Current:Home > InvestWrongful death suit against Disney serves as a warning to consumers when clicking ‘I agree’-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Wrongful death suit against Disney serves as a warning to consumers when clicking ‘I agree’
View Date:2024-12-23 20:34:17
A wrongful death lawsuit against Walt Disney Parks and Resorts is serving as a reminder to consumers of the importance of reading the fine print when signing up for a streaming service or smartphone app.
The lawsuit was filed by the family of a New York woman who died after eating at a restaurant in Disney Springs, an outdoor dining, shopping and entertainment complex in Florida owned by Disney.
Disney is arguing that the lawsuit should be dropped because the plaintiff, the woman’s husband, once signed up for a trial subscription of the Disney+ streaming service. That service, they argue, includes a subscriber agreement in which the customer agrees to settle any lawsuits against Disney out of court through arbitration.
Such agreements, which customers quickly consent to by clicking “I agree” when downloading an app or a streaming service, are so stacked against the consumer that it’s often difficult to offer good legal advice, said John Davisson, director of litigation at the Electronic Privacy Information Center.
“The consumer is presented with this contract and really doesn’t have an opportunity to negotiate the terms,” Davisson said. “It’s yes or no.”
What are the details of the lawsuit against Disney?
Kanokporn Tangsuan’s family says in the lawsuit that the 42-year-old New York doctor had a fatal allergic reaction after eating at an Irish pub in Disney Springs.
The lawsuit claims Tangsuan and her husband, Jeffrey Piccolo, and his mother decided to eat at Raglan Road in October 2023 because it was billed on Disney’s website as having “allergen free food.”
The suit alleges Tangsuan informed their server numerous times that she had a severe allergy to nuts and dairy products, and that the waiter “guaranteed” the food was allergen-free.
About 45 minutes after finishing their dinner, Tangsuan had difficulty breathing while out shopping, collapsed and died at a hospital, according to the lawsuit.
A medical examiner determined she died as a result of “anaphylaxis due to elevated levels of dairy and nut in her system,” the lawsuit said.
What is Disney’s position?
Disney said in a statement this week that it is “deeply saddened” by the family’s loss but stressed that the Irish pub, which also is being sued, is neither owned nor operated by the company.
More notably from a consumer protection standpoint, Disney argues that Piccolo had agreed to settle any lawsuits against Disney out of court through arbitration when he signed up for a one-month trial of Disney+ in 2019 and acknowledged that he had reviewed the fine print.
“The first page of the Subscriber Agreement states, in all capital letters, that ‘any dispute between You and Us, Except for Small Claims, is subject to a class action waiver and must be resolved by individual binding arbitration’,” the company wrote in a motion seeking to have the case dismissed.
Arbitration allows people to settle disputes without going to court and generally involves a neutral arbitrator who reviews arguments and evidence before making a binding decision, or award.
Piccolo’s lawyer, in a response filed this month, argued that it was “absurd” to believe that the more than 150 million subscribers to Disney+ have waived all rights to sue the company and its affiliates in perpetuity — especially when their case has nothing to do with the popular streaming service.
What can consumers do to protect themselves?
While it’s difficult to give consumers actionable advice when such agreements are so lopsided in favor of companies, Davisson suggested supporting lawmakers and regulators who are attentive to these issues.
The Federal Trade Commission has historically supported the idea of disclosure terms protecting companies, even though the agreements are often dense and hard for typical consumers to comprehend. But Davisson says there has been a shift among policymakers and federal regulators.
“Generally, it’s understood that it is literally impossible for consumers to read and interpret and fully understand all of the contracts that they’re being asked and expected by the law to agree to and abide by as they go about their day,” he said. “Especially in an increasingly online world in which we’re interacting with dozens or hundreds of platforms and services a day.”
___
Lewis reported from New York and Murphy from Oklahoma City.
veryGood! (5996)
Related
- Veterans face challenges starting small businesses but there are plenty of resources to help
- Roll Tide: Alabama books first March Madness trip to Final Four with defeat of Clemson
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Stamp Collection
- NASCAR at Richmond spring 2024: Start time, TV, streaming, lineup for Toyota Owners 400
- Armie Hammer Says His Mom Gifted Him a Vasectomy for His 38th Birthday
- A Power Line Debate Pits Environmental Allies Against Each Other in the Upper Midwest
- Alabama's Nate Oats called coaching luminaries in search of advice for struggling team
- Vague school rules at the root of millions of student suspensions
- Voters in Oakland oust Mayor Sheng Thao just 2 years into her term
- Second-half surge powers No. 11 NC State to unlikely Final Four berth with defeat of Duke
Ranking
- Horoscopes Today, November 9, 2024
- King Charles Celebrates Easter Alongside Queen Camilla in Rare Public Appearance Since Cancer Diagnosis
- Beyoncé's 'Cowboy Carter' becomes Spotify's most-streamed album in single day in 2024
- Visa, Mastercard agree to $30B deal with merchants. What it means for credit card holders.
- Mattel says it ‘deeply’ regrets misprint on ‘Wicked’ dolls packaging that links to porn site
- A woman, 19, is killed and 4 other people are wounded in a Chicago shooting early Sunday
- Phoenix gets measurable rainfall on Easter Sunday for the first time in 25 years.
- Brittany Mahomes Appears Makeup-Free as She Holds Both Kids Sterling and Bronze in Sweet Photo
Recommendation
-
Tesla issues 6th Cybertruck recall this year, with over 2,400 vehicles affected
-
South Carolina's biggest strength is its ability to steal opponents' souls
-
For years, we were told chocolate causes pimples. Have we been wrong all along?
-
Former US Rep. William Delahunt of Massachusetts has died at age 82
-
Cruise ship rescues 4 from disabled catamaran hundreds of miles off Bermuda, officials say
-
LSU's X-factors vs. Iowa in women's Elite Eight: Rebounding, keeping Reese on the floor
-
Kia recalls over 427,000 Telluride SUVs because they might roll away while parked
-
Alabama's Nate Oats called coaching luminaries in search of advice for struggling team